The University of Tennessee
Institute of Agriculture
A-Z Index  /  WebMail  /  Dept. Directory

Department of Animal Science

Glossary for April 2008 ENR$ Calculations
(alphabetical order)


  • "Best-fit" (for herd management level): Only three levels of herd management are presented. Average herd management is characterized by average conception rates (40%), average heifer survival (about 90% of heifers born actually survive to calve), average culling of pregnant cows (10% of pregnant cows culled), average age at first calving (26 months), and average calving interval (13 months). A cost of $1.50 per day for each day open is assumed in the calculation of ENR$. Days open are determined by a sire's estimated relative conception rate (ERCR) and a producer's herd management level. If your management is generally better than average (optimistic), pick above average. If you can only wish that your management were average (pessimistic), pick below average. If your herd situation doesn't quite fit any of these, pick the best one ("best-fit"), or run the program twice picking a different herd management level each time. Compare how bulls rank in your two choices and pick the bulls highest on both lists.

  • NOTE: Higher priced bulls rank higher for herds with above average management than they do for herds with below average management.  
  • Cheese Merit: Cheese merit (CM$) is a comprehensive index for those producers that sell their milk in a cheese market.  
  • ENR$: ENR$ is an economic index (see definition of index below) that estimates the expected net revenue from one unit of semen for an AI sire customed for a producer's milk market and herd management level. The starting point for ENR$ is Lifetime Net Merit, Lifetime Cheese Merit or Lifetime Fluid Merit depending on a producer's milk market.   ENR$ considers the cost of semen, the costs associated with a sire's estimated relative conception rate (ERCR), as well as revenues and costs associated with milk sales, feed, health, reproduction, and culling. Performance of daughters and future generations of descendants are included in the revenues and costs. Discounting of future revenues and costs is given proper consideration since there is a time lapse between the time the semen is purchased and the time a resulting daughter enters the milking string. ENR$ is expressed relative to the service from an average non-AI bull.
  • ERCR: ERCR or estimated relative conception rate, is a measure of conception rate of a service sire relative to service sires of herdmates which is calculated by Dairy Records Management Systems (DRMS). Only first services are used in an Animal Model program similar to the one used to compute production PTAs. Estimates are adjusted for the effects of each mate's early lactation energy-corrected-milk production, lactation number, stage of lactation, month of breeding, herd, year, birth year of bull and the interaction between bull and herd. Since ERCR has been proven to be an accurate predictor of future fertility, it should be useful to a dairy producer when choosing service sires. Because ERCR is determined from many services in many different herds, it is believed to be more accurate in identifying high, average, and low fertility bulls than a single herd estimate. ERCR was calculated from the AI breedings of Holstein and Jersey bulls in DHI herds that report to DRMS, AgSource in Wisconsin, and AgriTech Analytics in California. Unless noted, breeding records from the recent three years were used.

  • Fluid Merit (FM$): Fluid merit (FM$) is a comprehensive index for those producers that sell their milk in fluid markets.  
  • Index: Combination of two or more traits to get a single value; more important traits are given more weight and less important traits are given less weight. Many factors, including economic values, are taken into account.  
  • LIMITED NUMBER (in Step 4): Unless you choose to look at all April 2008 bulls, you can choose an upper or lower limit for a trait to get a shortened list.

  • Examples:
    1) choose an ENR$ minimum of 75 to get a list of bulls with ENR$ equal to or greater than $75,
    2) choose a maximum %DBH of 10 to get a list of bulls with %DBH of no greater than 10%. NOTE: Only can choose maximums for %DBH (only Holsteins) and semen price.  
  • Net Merit (NM$): In November 2000 a revised Net Merit (NM$), or more correctly Lifetime Net Merit, was put into use by USDA. NM$ measures the accumulated net profit over the lifetime of a bull's average daughter. This index was created for producers who sell milk based on milk, fat, and protein components.   
  • % DBH (Percent Difficult Births in Heifers): Percentage of difficult calvings (with some or considerable assistance needed) expected for a sire's calves born from heifers in an average herd. A score of 10 or lower for % DBH means less-than-average calving difficulty. ONLY AVAILABLE FOR HOLSTEINS.  
  • % Rel %DBH (Percent Reliability for Calving Ease): The accuracy of the %DBH. The closer the percent reliability is to 100, the more confidence we have in the %DBH presented. Reliability is primarily based on the number of calvings and herds represented in the %DBH. ONLY AVAILABLE FOR HOLSTEINS.  
  • % Rel. Yield (Percent Reliability Yield): Reliability measures the accuracy of PTA Yield. Percent reliability yield is composed of the reliabilities of milk, fat and protein weighted as they are in Net Merit $.  The closer the percent reliability is to 100, the more confidence we have in the PTA Yield presented. Reliability is primarily based on the number of daughters and herds for which Net Merit $ can be calculated.  
  • Productive Life (PL): An estimate of daughter survival through seven years of age. Actual culling data from USDA is combined with linear type data from the Holstein Association to get the best estimate of productive life available. Proofs from bulls with only young daughters are impacted more by the type traits than bulls with older daughters.  
  • PTA (Predicted Transmitting Ability): The best estimate of an animal's genetic superiority or inferiority.  
  • PTA Fat: PTA for butterfat production in pounds. This figure compares the expected production of future mature daughters. PTA Fat is expressed relative to an average cow born in 1995. Example: a bull with a PTA Fat value of 75 will have daughters that on average produce 25 more lbs. of fat than bulls with PTA Fat of 50 lbs.  
  • PTA Milk: PTA for milk production in pounds. This compares the expected production of future mature daughters. PTA Milk is expressed relative to an average cow born in 1995. Example: a bull with 2000 lbs. of PTA milk will have daughters that on average produce 1000 lbs. more milk than a bull with 1000 lbs. of PTA Milk.  
  • PTA Protein: PTA for protein production in pounds. This figure compares the expected production of future mature daughters. PTA Protein is expressed relative to an average cow born in 1995. Example: a bull with a PTA Protein of 60 will have daughters that on average produce 20 lbs. more protein than bulls with PTA Protein of 40 lbs.  
  • Sample codes (abbreviated Smp Cd in reports):

  • S-Stud Sample: Designates a bull in a standard (S) progeny test program of an AI business. S-coded bulls must be sampled by semen distributed to at least 40 herds qualifying for USDA genetic evaluations. Sampling organizations cannot sample bulls with the intention of leasing them to another organization.
    O-Other Sample Programs: Miscellaneous programs.
    NOTE: A bull without a sampling code designates that the bull was proven initially or totally outside of the United States but his semen is currently available in the United States.  
  • Semen Price: National price per unit of semen as released by AI organizations. Prices may vary from region to region. If the price per unit of semen changes, the ENR$ value changes as well. Example: The national semen price is $15 but you can purchase the semen for $10 per unit. The ENR$ value was $50 with the semen price at $15. Add $5 to the old ENR$ to get a new ENR$ value of $55 with the semen price at $10.  
  • Somatic Cell Score (SCS): The PTA for SCS is used to improve mastitis resistance. Bulls with low PTA for SCS (less than 3.0) are expected to have daughters with lower mastitis than bulls with high PTA for SCS (greater than 3.5). Example: Assume on average that 20% of the first lactation cows in a herd have one or more clinical episodes in first lactation. Expect about 15% of the daughters of a bull with a 2.8 PTA for SCS to have one or more episodes in first lactation and about 25% of the daughters of a bull with a 3.8 PTA for SCS to have one or more episodes in first lactation.

  • Average first-lactation SCS for cows born in 2000 by breed were: 2.97 for Ayrshire, 2.94 for Brown Swiss, 3.31 for Guernsey, 3.09 for Holstein, 3.34 for Jersey, and 3.07 for Milking Shorthorn.